The onions are browning, the chili powder is measured out, and the can you grabbed from the back of the pantry turns out to be pinto, not kidney. Or you are making red beans and rice, a three-bean salad, or a pot of minestrone, and the recipe was written by someone who clearly assumed everyone keeps two cans of kidney beans on hand. Good news: this is one of the easiest swaps in the kitchen.
Kidney beans earn their spot in so many recipes for one main reason: they hold their shape. They are big, firm, and thick-skinned, so they survive hours in a chili pot and stay whole in a vinegary salad. The best substitute depends on which of those jobs they were doing, and whether you want a bean that stays firm or one that melts into the sauce.
So the substitutes below are grouped by dish, with exact amounts for each. All swaps assume the standard unit: one 15-ounce can, drained and rinsed, which is about 1 1/2 cups of cooked beans.
The Quick List
- Pinto beans — the closest all-purpose swap, especially for chili
- Black beans — a firm, dark bean for chili, soups, and bowls
- Small red beans or pink beans — the best pick for red beans and rice and other creamy stewed beans
- Cranberry (borlotti) beans — for minestrone, Italian soups, and stews
- Cannellini beans — the "white kidney bean," for soups, salads, and pasta e fagioli
- Chickpeas — the firmest swap for three-bean salads and grain bowls
- Black-eyed peas — for cold bean salads and Southern-style stews
- Brown or green lentils — the no-soak pick when you have no cans, with more protein and iron
- Black soybeans — the low-carb, high-protein swap for chili
Canned vs. Dried Kidney Beans (and One Safety Rule)
Sometimes the problem is not the bean but the form. If the recipe says canned and you only have dried, here are the numbers:
- 1 can (15 ounces), drained = about 1 1/2 cups cooked beans
- 1/2 cup dried kidney beans = about 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 cups cooked, so plan on a heaping 1/2 cup dried per can
- 1 pound dried beans (about 2 1/2 cups) = roughly 5 to 6 cups cooked, or 3 1/2 to 4 cans
Dried kidney beans come with a rule no other common bean needs quite as badly. Raw red kidney beans are loaded with a natural lectin called phytohaemagglutinin, and according to Kansas State University food safety specialists, eating as few as four or five undercooked ones can cause severe vomiting. A proper boil destroys it. Their FDA-based advice: soak the beans for at least five hours, drain, then boil them in fresh water for at least 30 minutes.
That last step matters most for slow cooker recipes. University of Illinois Extension notes that beans in a slow cooker often reach only about 167F inside, well short of the 212F the toxin needs, and that slowly heating raw beans can actually make them more toxic. So if your chili goes in a slow cooker, either use canned kidney beans or boil soaked dried ones hard for 30 minutes first. Canned kidney beans are already fully cooked and safe straight from the can. For the full process, see our guide on how to cook dried beans from scratch.
Substitutes for Kidney Beans in Chili, Soups, and Stews
This is where kidney beans do most of their work. In a long simmer, they stay whole and meaty while the sauce thickens around them, and dark red kidney beans keep the pot looking deep and rich. The best swaps are beans that can take at least 30 minutes of simmering without falling apart.
1. Pinto Beans
- Swap: 1 can kidney beans → 1 can pinto beans, drained and rinsed (1:1)
- Best for: Chili, chili mac, taco soup, bean burritos, and baked bean dishes
- Skip it for: Cold salads, where they are softer than kidney beans and can break when tossed
- Health notes: A cup of cooked pinto beans has 245 calories, 15.4 g of protein, and 15.4 g of fiber, a little more fiber than the 225 calories, 15.4 g of protein, and 13.1 g of fiber in a cup of red kidney beans
If you only remember one swap, make it this one. Pinto beans are the other classic chili bean, and plenty of Southwestern and home-style chili recipes call for them instead of kidney beans. They are creamier and a little smaller, with thinner skins, so they soften more over a long simmer and some of them break down into the sauce. That is not a flaw; it makes a thicker, velvety chili. If you want more whole beans in the finished pot, stir the pintos in during the last 30 minutes instead of at the start.
Flavor-wise, pintos are a touch milder and earthier. A little extra chili powder or a pinch of smoked paprika covers the difference. The color shifts from deep red to a pinkish brown, which nobody notices once the tomatoes go in.
2. Black Beans
- Swap: 1 can kidney beans → 1 can black beans, drained and rinsed (1:1)
- Best for: Chili, Tex-Mex soups, burrito bowls, and salsas
- Skip it for: Light-colored soups and pasta dishes, where they turn everything gray
- Health notes: Nearly identical. A cup of black beans has 227 calories, 15.2 g of protein, and 15 g of fiber, with a bit more folate (256 mcg vs. 230 mcg)
Black beans are smaller than kidney beans but hold their shape almost as well, and they keep a chili dark and hearty. They taste a little earthier and less "beany" than kidney beans, which suits cumin-heavy Tex-Mex chili especially well. In a chili that calls for two cans of kidney beans, one can of black and one of pinto is a great combination: you get the whole-bean bite from the black beans and the creamy body from the pintos.
Running the swap the other way? Our black bean substitutes guide covers what to use when the black beans are the missing can.
3. Cranberry (Borlotti) Beans
- Swap: 1 can kidney beans → 1 can cranberry or borlotti beans, drained and rinsed (1:1)
- Best for: Minestrone, pasta e fagioli, Italian bean soups, and hearty stews
- Skip it for: Chili, if you want the classic deep red color, since they cook up a pale pinkish tan
- Health notes: The standout here for folate. A cup of cooked cranberry beans has 241 calories, 16.5 g of protein, 15.2 g of fiber, and 366 mcg of folate, 92 percent of the Daily Value and about 60 percent more than kidney beans
Cranberry beans, sold as borlotti beans in Italian groceries and Roman beans in some stores, are close to kidney beans in size and have a gorgeous speckled skin that fades to a uniform tan when cooked. They are creamier inside than kidney beans, with a mild, slightly chestnut-like flavor, and they are the traditional bean in many Italian soups. In minestrone they are arguably an upgrade: they give the broth more body without going mushy.
Look for canned borlotti beans in the Italian section, or dried cranberry beans in the bulk bins and at farmers markets in late summer, when fresh shelling ones show up too.
4. Brown or Green Lentils
- Swap: 1 can kidney beans → 1 1/2 cups cooked brown or green lentils (from about 2/3 cup dried, simmered 20 to 25 minutes)
- Best for: Chili, soups, stews, and sloppy joe-style fillings
- Skip it for: Salads, red beans and rice, and any dish where you want whole, distinct beans
- Health notes: A cup of cooked lentils has 230 calories, 17.9 g of protein, 15.6 g of fiber, and 6.6 mg of iron, about 25 percent more iron than the 5.2 mg in kidney beans
Lentils are the rescue when you have no canned beans at all, because they need no soaking and cook in about 20 minutes. That makes them the safest way to use a dried legume on a weeknight, with none of the kidney bean boiling rules. You can even add rinsed dried lentils straight to a simmering chili: use about 2/3 cup dried per can of beans, add an extra 1 1/2 to 2 cups of broth or water so they have liquid to absorb, and simmer until tender, 25 to 30 minutes.
The texture change is real. Lentils make a chili that is thicker and more like a ground meat chili than a bean chili, which many people love, especially in a vegetarian pot. Use brown or green lentils, not red ones, which collapse into a puree. Our lentil substitutes guide covers the differences between the types.
5. Black Soybeans
- Swap: 1 can kidney beans → 1 can black soybeans, drained and rinsed (1:1)
- Best for: Low-carb and keto chili, soups, and salads
- Skip it for: Red beans and rice and anything mashed or creamy, because they never soften fully
- Health notes: A cup of cooked mature soybeans has 28.6 g of protein and 17.1 g of carbohydrate (10.3 g of it fiber), against 15.4 g of protein and 40.4 g of carbohydrate in a cup of kidney beans. They have more fat too, about 15 g per cup, mostly unsaturated
Black soybeans are the go-to bean on low-carb plans, where regular beans are often off the menu. They are about the size of a small kidney bean, firm and nutty, and they stay al dente no matter how long the chili simmers, so they mimic that kidney bean bite surprisingly well. The figures above are for regular mature soybeans; black soybeans are very similar, but brands vary, so check the label if you are counting carbs closely. Find them canned in health food stores and online.
Substitutes for Kidney Beans in Red Beans and Rice
New Orleans red beans and rice is usually made with red kidney beans that are simmered for hours until some of them break down into a creamy, gravy-like sauce. Here you want a bean that does the opposite of a chili bean: one that gets soft and creamy. Pinto beans from above work well. One option is even better.
6. Small Red Beans or Pink Beans
- Swap: 1 can kidney beans → 1 can small red beans or pink beans, drained and rinsed (1:1)
- Best for: Red beans and rice, Caribbean and Central American stewed beans, and rajma-style curries
- Skip it for: Cold salads, where they are too soft to toss
Small red beans look like miniature kidney beans and taste much the same, but their thinner skins and creamier centers mean they break down faster in a long simmer. For red beans and rice, that is exactly the goal, and many Louisiana cooks use them interchangeably with kidney beans. Pink beans (habichuelas rosadas) are a close cousin and are the everyday bean in Puerto Rican and Dominican stewed beans. Find both in the Latin foods aisle.
The classic trick works with any of these beans: once they are tender, mash about a cup of them against the side of the pot with a wooden spoon and stir it back in. The sauce turns thick and creamy in minutes. If you are also out of the seasoning blend, our Cajun seasoning guide has an easy homemade version.
The same beans also work in Indian rajma, a kidney bean curry. Pinto beans are another good choice there; both soak up the spiced tomato gravy beautifully and cook down a little softer than kidney beans, so you can shorten the simmer by 10 minutes or so.
Substitutes for Kidney Beans in Salads
Three-bean salad, kidney bean and corn salad, and chopped salads need a bean that stays firm when tossed, does not get mushy in a vinegar dressing, and tastes good cold. That rules out most of the creamy beans above.
7. Chickpeas
- Swap: 1 can kidney beans → 1 can chickpeas, drained and rinsed (1:1)
- Best for: Three-bean salad, chopped salads, grain bowls, and roasted bean snacks
- Skip it for: Red beans and rice and creamy stewed beans, where they never go soft
- Health notes: A cup of chickpeas has 269 calories, 14.5 g of protein, and 12.5 g of fiber, with a bit more fat (about 4 g) than kidney beans
Chickpeas are the one bean firmer than kidney beans, which makes them the best choice for any salad that gets tossed, stored, and served the next day. Plenty of three-bean salad recipes already include them, so if you are missing the kidney beans, just double up on chickpeas alongside the green and wax beans. They are nuttier and paler, so the salad looks a little different, but the texture is even better. They also work in chili, holding their shape for hours, though they never melt into the sauce the way kidney beans partly do.
For more on this bean, our chickpea substitutes guide runs the swap in the other direction.
8. Cannellini Beans (White Kidney Beans)
- Swap: 1 can red kidney beans → 1 can cannellini beans, drained and rinsed (1:1)
- Best for: Italian bean salads, minestrone, pasta e fagioli, and white chili
- Skip it for: Classic red chili and three-bean salad, if you want the color contrast
Cannellini are often labeled "white kidney beans," and for good reason: they are the same shape and size, just white instead of red. They are creamier and milder than red kidney beans, with thinner skins, and they hold their shape well enough for a salad as long as you toss them gently. They are the natural swap in any Italian dish, and in minestrone they are just as traditional as the red ones. One note if you cook them from dried: cannellini carry about a third as much of the same lectin, so give them the same soak and 30-minute boil.
For more Italian-style options, see our cannellini bean substitutes guide.
9. Black-Eyed Peas
- Swap: 1 can kidney beans → 1 can black-eyed peas, drained and rinsed (1:1)
- Best for: Cold bean salads, "Texas caviar" salsas, and Southern-style stews with greens
- Skip it for: Chili that simmers for hours, where they soften more than kidney beans
Black-eyed peas are smaller and softer than kidney beans, with a mild, earthy flavor and a creamy center. They soak up a tangy dressing beautifully, which is why they are the base of Texas caviar, and they work well in a kidney bean and corn salad with the same dressing. Fold them in gently and they stay whole. In stews, add them in the last 20 minutes so they do not fall apart.
One tip for any bean in a salad: rinse well, drain for a few minutes, and pat dry. Wet beans water down the dressing, and a watery salad is a bigger problem than which bean you chose.
Healthier Upgrades
Kidney beans are already one of the most nourishing foods in the pantry. A cup has 15 g of protein and 13 g of fiber, plus 5.2 mg of iron (29 percent of the Daily Value), 58 percent of the Daily Value for folate, and 713 mg of potassium, with less than 1 g of fat. There is no health reason to swap them out. But if you are choosing a substitute anyway, a few bring something extra:
- Lentils for more protein and iron. 17.9 g of protein and 6.6 mg of iron per cup, and they cook in 20 minutes. A squeeze of lime or the tomatoes in a chili help your body absorb that plant iron.
- Pinto or cranberry beans for more fiber. About 15 g per cup, roughly 2 g more than kidney beans, and cranberry beans bring the most folate of anything here.
- Black soybeans for more protein and fewer carbs. Nearly twice the protein and less than half the carbohydrate, though with more fat and calories.
- A mix of beans for plant diversity. Use one can of kidney beans and one of pinto or black in your next chili instead of two of the same, and that is two different plants instead of one. It adds up if you are aiming for 30 different plants a week for your gut.
Whatever bean you use, rinse it. Draining and rinsing canned beans washes away a good part of the sodium in the canning liquid, and no-salt-added cans cut most of it. If beans tend to leave you uncomfortable, our post on why beans give you gas has practical fixes that apply to every bean on this list.
Want to see what a swap does to your own recipe before you cook? In Eat Well Planner, the Recipe Playground lets you change the kidney beans in your chili to lentils, pinto beans, or black soybeans and watch the nutrition score, fiber, and protein update live. Every new bean you add also counts toward your Plant Points.
Take the Guesswork Out of Eating Well
Eat Well Planner helps you organize your favorite recipes, plan balanced meals, and automatically generate shopping lists — all in one place. Whether you're tracking macros, managing dietary restrictions, or just trying to stop asking "what's for dinner?", we've got you covered.
Our AI-powered tools can adapt any recipe to your dietary needs, help you discover new meals you'll love, and even log your nutrition effortlessly. It's meal planning made simple.
Start Organizing Your Meals — FreeWhat Not to Use
- Raw dried kidney beans in a slow cooker. They need a hard 30-minute boil first, as covered above. Use canned, or boil soaked dried beans before they go in.
- Baked beans or chili beans in sauce. They are sweetened and seasoned, and that sauce will take over a salad or throw off the seasoning in your chili. Use plain canned beans.
- Red lentils. They dissolve into a puree in about 15 minutes. Fine for thickening a soup, but they will not stand in for whole beans in chili, salads, or red beans and rice.
- Lima or butter beans in chili. They are big and creamy, but they soften quickly and their buttery flavor can clash with chili spices. They are better in salads and Southern stews.
Which Substitute Fits Your Recipe?
For chili, a can of pinto or black beans is the answer, and nobody at the table will notice. Reach for small red beans in red beans and rice, cranberry or cannellini beans in Italian soups, chickpeas in salads, and lentils when the pantry has no cans at all.
Still not sure which one suits the dish in front of you? Eat Well Planner's AI Recipe Chat knows the full recipe you are cooking, so you can ask "I am out of kidney beans, what should I use in this?" and get an answer for that dish, not a general list. And if chili is on the menu, our healthier beef chili makeover shows how a few smart swaps, beans included, make the bowl even more filling.